There are people who form part of the anti-cochlear implant brigade, who feed other people a load of bovine excrement about cochlear implants. Motives range from ignorance, to maintaining the status quo, to ulterior motives (as in financial ones). This leads to disappointment in some people seeking implantation and in some cases leads to people discounting the operation.
I don't think there's anything wrong with people having an opinion - positive or otherwise - but
it's not fair to influence people with statements that are factually incorrect, as well as subjective.
These are some of the myths that go around cochlear implants:
Myth 1) Cochlear implants involve implantation into the brain
Truth: The implant does not come anywhere near the brain. The electrodes are implanted into the cochlea which contains the auditory nerve. At no time is the brain ever exposed or touched.
Myth 2) Someone told me someone died after having an implant
Truth: Nobody has ever died from a cochlear implantation. There have been some cases of bacterial meningitis in implantees but this can be avoided through the appropriate vaccination prior to surgery, and the use of prophylactic antibiotics post surgery. There is also no clear evidence that these infections occurred BECAUSE of the implant.
Myth 3) People who have a cochlear implant are not deaf as it restores normal hearing
Truth: Just like a person who wears spectacles is always short sighted, wearing the cochlear implant does not make a person less deaf (if anything, any residual hearing tends to be destroyed). What the implant does is that it reduces the effect of deafness.
Myth 4) Medical people have financial motives for suggesting a person for an implant
Truth: In some cases, it works against the doctor or an audiologist to suggest a person for an implant, either because they will have to refer the deaf person to someone else, or possibly through loss of custom in hearing aids, batteries etc.
Myth 5) Implantees are not permitted to swim
Truth Like hearing aid wearer's, you have to remove your device before you swim. But you can still have showers, swim etc.
Myth 6) New and improved technology require additional surgeries to be availed of
In reality, the implanted unit is designed to last forever, the external part, on the other hand, can be upgraded as new technology and software becomes available.
In addition, I have heard comments about parents trying to fix a child because they do not accept him or her because s/he is deaf. I find this a totally spurious comment, because, logically, a parent who has a short-sighted child should not buy spectacles for their child as they do not accept them
as they are. So, what is the logic behind this statement, as it is fallacious to me?
I have also heard that Implantees become emarginalised, forming part of neither the deaf world, neither the hearing. But, many of implantees do not desire to form part of the deaf world as they never formed part of it. Others feel that the deaf world is hostile to them because they have been implanted, so they have no real choice.
I realise that some of these statements are pretty strong (enter hate mail from people who don't agree with me :( ) but I feel equally strong about this and believe that people should be given choice. If a person decides not to get an implant, that's fine, nobody is battering doors down to force people to get implants, but on the other hand people shouldn't stay whining if they find difficulties later in life that could have been overcome, partially or fully, by getting an implant.